May 22, 2011

More Jobim Tunes With Borrowed Chords

This post is a sort of necessary follow-up to Jobim’s “Out of Nowhere” Tunes (March 28). There are a few more early Antonio Carlos Jobim tunes with chord sequences borrowed from the “Great American Songbook.” If you are a jazz player, you might be interested in this info just from a theory angle; but knowing this stuff also has the practical value of helping you to insert silly quotes into your solos. Here are the tunes:
Girl From Ipanema (1962): The A section harmony is borrowed from “Take the A Train,” with tritone substitutions for the V chords. Here’s a clip of Jobim playing his own tune, and quoting “A Train.” This is from an all-star jam at a tribute to Jobim. The date is listed as 2002 on the YouTube clip, but I think it was really 1993 (Jobim died in 1994).
The “Ipanema” bridge is harder to solo over than one might think. My solution is to see the bridge as a series of Imaj7 to IVdom chords: Gbmaj7 to B7, then A6 (disguised as F#m7) to D7, then Bb6 (disguised as Gm7) to Eb7, followed by a turnaround in F to set up the last A section. Each of these Imaj7 to IVdom sequences can be treated in a blues sort of way, with guide tones Bb to A, then C# to C, then D to Db. Try thinking of it as three blues sequences, with the guide tones indicating the major third of the key to the minor third of the key. The progression makes more sense that way, and you can get some blues mileage out of it. Jobim inverted the chords to create a more interesting bass line, which obscures their functional logic. (Well, that’s my take, anyway.)
So Danco Samba (1962): This tune has an “A Train” A section, and a “Satin Doll” bridge. (And of course, the A section of “A Train” was itself borrowed from the earlier “Exactly Like You.”)
Wave (1967): The 12-bar A section is a disguised blues, crammed with extra changes. The I and IV are right where they should be in a blues (bars 1 and 5), and the Dm7 G7 dorian vamp in bars 11 and 12 is right where a blues would have had a return to the tonic D7. These “landmark” spots in bars 5 and 11 are each prepared backwards with a series of dominant chords or II V’s that, when played forwards, resolve nicely into each other. It’s the same compositional process as Charlie Parker’s “Blues for Alice,” with a different end result. As in “Blues for Alice,” the I and IV are major 7 chords. Note the blues lick in bars 10-11 of the A section.
One-note Samba (1959): The A section is “I Got Rhythm,” with each chord 4 beats instead of 2 beats, and tritone subs in bars 2, 4, 6, 8, 14, 15, 26. 28, 30, and 32. The last A section has a clever alteration in the last 4 bars. Actually, to be a bit more accurate, it’s based on “Rhythm changes,” i.e. the chord changes evolved by jazz players to make the original Gershwin tune more improv-friendly. The melody of the A section is very likely inspired by the verse (introduction) to Cole Porter's "Night and Day."
Chega de Saudade (1958): A great early composition, sometimes called the first bossa nova tune. The A section uses essentially the same chords as the 1944 choro “Saxofone, Porque Choras.” The B section (where it goes into the key of D major) is “When You Wish Upon a Star,” from the Disney movie,"Pinocchio." This borrowed chord sequence goes for 16 measures. You can amuse your audience and your fellow band members with this lengthy quote, at least until everyone is thoroughly bored with hearing it. Then you can keep doing it, like telling a bad joke over and over again. The shape of the melody in bars 1-6 references “Bye Bye Blues,” although “Chega” is in minor, and the chords are completely different.
There’s also “How Insensitive,” which is partly based on Chopin’s Prelude #4 in E minor. I only mention this to round out this article. I’m not sure how to get a good quote out of it.
And don’t forget the corny “Star Trek” quote that you can use on all of those “Out of Nowhere” tunes (see the March 28 post).

Late addition: "Este seu olhar," which pretty much follows the harmonic template of Rodgers and Hart's "Bewitched" - see this post. Another Jobim tune, "So em teus bracos," isn't too far off.

Another one: Jobim’s “Andorinha,” bars 17-24 and again in bars 33-40, uses the progression found in “Stella by Starlight,” bars 25-32.

7 comments:

Johnny 7 said...

Peter,
Jobim on Jobim.
As you and Dan Nieckarz witnessed, a few years ago:
We were playing our (then regular Sat gig), when during my "Look to the Sky" 2nd chorus flute solo, I started with 2 repeated notes that triggered the head of Jobim's "Fotografia" to the very end.
J7.

Johnny 7 said...

Maybe pertinent,...maybe not.

Iñaki L.G. said...

Awesome research that proves Jobim's genius, as he improves once and again his borrowed templates. Only comparable to Cole Porter, best American composer (American as Brazil is).

adamponting said...

Possibly related:

The song "More Than You Know" (1929) (which I learnt from Billie Holiday's version) seems very similar to Pixinguinha's "Carinhoso" (1917) in a lot of ways. e.g. First phrase is an anacrusis of 3 triplet half-notes followed by a 4th note on the 1. Repeat. Then third phrase goes up a minor third. Repeat the same triplet rhythm at the end of the A sections, over II-V-I harmony. And the melody and chords in the bridge—and even more, the spirit—seem much too close for coincidence. Even the first phrase of the melody of More Than You Know, on the 5-#5-6, is the harmony at the top of Carinhoso. More Than You Know seems almost like Carinhoso crammed into 32-bar AABA form.

I like the bridge of MTYK better though, one of my very favourite bridges.

Pixinguinha version of Carinhoso

Yamandu Costa version sung by the audience

Helen Morgan 1929 version of More Than You Know.

Peter Spitzer said...

Adam, thanks for the comment! I agree about the similarity. The timeline makes it just possible that Vincent Youmans took some inspiration from “Carinhoso.” According to this writeup - https://lyricalbrazil.com/2016/06/13/carinhoso/ - although Pixinguinha wrote the tune in 1917, it was not recorded and released until 1928, just barely in time for Youmans to have heard it and used those song elements in “More Than You Know,” which first appeared in a Broadway musical in 1929. It seems like a stretch to think that Youmans would have been aware of that first “Carinhoso” recording (an instrumental; the song did not achieve popularity in Brazil until lyrics were added in a 1936 version), but it’s not out of the question. One might think that Youmans was aware of Brazilian culture because he wrote songs for the movie “Flying Down to Rio,” but that wasn’t until 1933.

And thanks also for the links. Yamandu Costa is always wonderful!

adamponting said...

Ah thanks a lot for the further research! Who knows. A last couple of details:

It says here that Pixinguinha gave various dates from 1916-25 for its composition, and said in the 1960s "I composed “Carinhoso” more or less in 1920. It was an instrumental piece, with a lot of influence from American jazz”. Maybe both songs were influenced by a third US song!

The 1929 recording was with RCA Victor's Victor Brazilian Orchestra (1929-35), so a major US label. e.g. Image of a label on a VBO disc from 1937 made in USA

Peter Spitzer said...

Even in 1920 as opposed to 1917, American jazz was barely formed. Pixinguinha can be forgiven some imprecision when he said that in the 1960s, but I wonder what he meant by saying that “Carinhoso” was “influenced by jazz.” “Carinhoso” doesn’t have any blue notes, and I’m pretty sure percussion had long been a Brazilian thing. Maybe he meant a quasi-Dixie instrumental approach, with one horn playing the melody, another playing fills? The jazz influence is far more obvious in choros starting in the later 1920s, in harmonies and in melodic interpretation. Just my impression as a US jazz player and choro fan.